Christoph Brunner

Force Majeure and Hardship under General Contract Principles: Exemption for Non-Performance in International Arbitration Christoph Brunner

Lawyers involved in international commercial transactions know well that unforeseen events affecting the performance of a party often arise. Not surprisingly, exemptions for non-performance are dealt with in a significant number of arbitral awards. This very useful book thoroughly analyzes contemporary approaches, particularly as manifested in case law, to the scope and content of the principles of exemption for non-performance which are commonly referred to as ?force majeure? and ?hardship.? The author shows that the ?general principles of law? approach addresses this concern most effectively.

Generally accepted and understood by the business world at large, this approach encompasses principles of international commercial contracts derived from a variety of legal systems. Its most important ?restatements? are found in the 1980 United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG) and the UNIDROIT Principles of International Commercial Contracts (UPICC).

Establishing specific standards and ?case groups? for the exemptions under review, the analysis treats such recurring elements as the following:

• contractual risk allocations;
• unforeseeability of an impediment;
• impediments beyond the typical sphere of risk and control of the obligor;
• responsibility for third parties (subcontractors, suppliers);
• legal impediments (acts of public authority) and effect of mandatory rules;
• involvement of states or state enterprises;
• interpretation of force majeure and hardship clauses;
• hardship threshold test;
• frustration of purpose;
• irreconcilable differences;
• comparison with exemptions under domestic legal systems (impossibility of performance, frustration of contract, impracticability)

The book is a major contribution to the development of the use of general principles of law in international commercial arbitration. It may be used as a comprehensive commentary on the force majeure and hardship provisions of the UPICC, as well as on Art. 79 of the CISG. In addition, as an insightful investigation into the fundamental question of the limits of the principle of sanctity of contracts, this book is sure to capture the attention of business lawyers and interested academics everywhere.